Answers For [Actual Test] - A Second Look at Twin Studies IELTS Reading Answer Key & Explanations

[Actual Test] - A Second Look at Twin Studies

More than a century after Galton's observation, twin studies remain a favorite tool of behavioral geneticists. Researchers have used twin studies to try to disentangle the environmental and genetic backgrounds of a cornucopia of traits, from aggression to intelligence to schizophrenia to alcohol dependence.

But despite the popularity of twin studies, some psychologists have long questioned assumptions that underline them, like the supposition that fraternal and identical twins share equal environments or that people choose mates with traits unlike their own. 1The equal environments assumption, for example, has been debated for at least 40 years. Many researchers have found evidence that the assumption is valid, but others remain skeptical.

Overall, twin studies assumptions remain controversial, says psychologist James Jaccard, PhD, a psychologist who studies statistical methods at the University at Albany of the State University of New York. 2In response, though, researchers are working to expand and develop twin study designs and statistical methods. 2-3And while the assumptions question remains a stumbling block for some researchers, many agree twin studies will continue to be an important tool, along with emerging genome and molecular research methods, in shedding light on human behavioral genetics.

4Monozygotic (identical) twins share all of their genes, while dizygotic (fraternal) twins share only about 50 percent of them. 8The classical twin study design relies on studying twins raised in the same family environments. 4So, if a researcher compares the similarity between sets of identical twins to the similarity between sets of fraternal twins for a particular trait, then any excess likeness between the identical twins should be due to genes rather than environment.

Researchers use this method, and variations on it, to estimate the heritability of traits: The percentage of variance in a population due to genes. The assumptions those studies rest on, questioned by some psychologists, including, in recent work: 9Modern twin studies also try to quantify the effect of a person's shared environment (family) and unique environment (the individual events that shape a life) on a trait.

Random mating. Twin researchers assume that people are as likely to choose partners who are different from themselves as they are to choose partners who are similar for a particular trait. If, instead, people tend to choose mates like themselves, then fraternal twins could share more than 50 percent of their genes – and hence more similarities on genetically influenced traits, because they would receive similar genes from their mothers and fathers.

Equal environments. Twin researchers also assume that fraternal and identical twins raised in the same homes experience equally similar environments. But some research suggests that parents, teachers, peers and others may treat identical twins more similarly than fraternal twins.

Gene-environment interaction. Some researchers think that interaction between genes and environment, rather than genes and environment separately, may influence many traits. A recent study from Science by Avshalom Caspi, PhD, of King's College London, for example, suggests that a gene might moderate propensity for violence, particularly in people who are severely maltreated as children. Many twin study designs don't take this type of complication into account.

Genetic mechanisms. Traits can be inherited through different genetic mechanisms. {[For traits governed by dominant genetic mechanisms, a dominant gene inherited from one parent trumps a recessive gene inherited from the other parent: If a person inherits a recessive gene for blue eyes from one parent and a dominant gene for brown eyes from the other parent, then the dominant brown gene wins, and the person's eyes are brown.

Additive genetic mechanisms, in contrast, mix together - a plant that receives on red gene and one white gene might, if the genes are additive, turn out pink.][5]} 6Epistatic mechanisms are complex cases where interactions among multiple genes may determine the outcome of one trait. Twin studies, in general, assume that only one type of genetic mechanism – usually additive – is operating for a particular trait.

Twin researchers acknowledge that these and other limitations exist. But, they say, the limitations don't negate the usefulness of twin studies. For traits that are substantially influenced by heredity, the approximately two-fold difference in genetic similarity between two types of twins should outweigh any complications, says John Hewitt, PhD, director of the Institute for Behavioral Genetics at the University of Colorado at Boulder.

And the extent to which different assumptions matter may depend on which trait is being studied. Studies have suggested, for example, that people are more likely to select mates with similar levels of intelligence than they are mates with similar levels of neuroticism, extraversion and other personality traits. So, researchers who use twins to study intelligence might have to worry more about nonrandom matting than researchers who study personality.

Twin study designs and statistical analysis methods are also constantly evolving and improving. 10The original twin study design has expanded to include studies of twins' extended families, longitudinal studies and other variations. Some of these variations allow researchers to address previous limitations – they can investigate the effects of nonrandom matting, for example, by including the spouses of twins in studies. In fact, says psychologist Dorret Bomsma, PhD, of Vrije University in the Netherlands, all of these assumptions can be tested, given the proper data. She argues that she should not be seen as assumptions at all, but instead as mechanisms whose relevance can be tested using study designs that go beyond the classical twin study design.

Analysis methods, likewise, don't remain static. "People are always thinking about ways to improve the analyses," Hewitt says. Jaccard acknowledges that this is true. "For some designs, we don't have to make as strong assumptions as we used to make," he says. "Instead of having to assume away four constructs, we only have to assume away two or three".

11In the age of molecular genetics, meanwhile, the classical twin study design is only one aspect of genetics research., 7-12Twin studies estimate the heritability of a trait, but molecular genetics attempts to pinpoint the effects of a particular gene.

The future of twin research will involve combining traditional twin studies with molecular genetics research, according to Hewitt, who believes that day is already here. "When we conduct a study of twins these days, we always get DNA on everyone," Hewitt says. "And we'll use that DNA to try and identify specific individual genes that contribute to the overall pattern of heritability".

Questions 1-7

Do the following statements agree with the claims of the writer in Reading Passage 1?

On your answer sheet please write

TRUE if the statement is true

FALSE if the statement is false

NOT GIVEN if the information is not given in the passage.

1

The environmental assumptions for twin studies have been challenged for a long time.

Correct answer: TRUE

2

Scientists only developed three methods to study human behavioral genetics.

Correct answer: NOT GIVEN

3

Questioning previous on assumptions has made twin studies a useless tool.

Correct answer: FALSE

4

Identical twins share more similarities than fraternal twins.

Correct answer: TRUE

5

Because of an addictive genetic mechanism, people will inherit dominant genes from their parents.

Correct answer: FALSE

6

Numerous genetic elements may join together to determine the result of one trait.

Correct answer: TRUE

7

Twin studies investigate the effect of a single gene.

Correct answer: FALSE

Questions 8-12

Choose your answer from the list below and write them in boxes 8-12 on your answer sheet.

behavioral genetics

longitudinal studies

molecular genetics

restrictions

obstacles

environment

unique environment

heritability

same family

accuracies

assumptions

acknowledges

appropriate figures

identical

distinct

NB There are more words than spaces so you will not use them all.

Complete the summary below.

Twin studies are constantly evolving and improving. The classical twin study design is on the basis of studying twins raised in the 8 (same family) . Modern twin studies try to quantify the effect of a person's family and 9 (unique environment) on a trait. Twin researchers acknowledge that some assumptions and limitations exist and expand the original twin study to include studies of twins' extended families, 10 (longitudinal studies) and other variations. In the time of 11 (molecular genetics) , the classical twin study has its limitation. It does not pinpoint the implication of the particular gene, although it helps to assess individual's 12 (heritability) .

Answers For [Actual Test] - A Second Look at Twin Studies

Answers and detail explain for [Actual Test] - A Second Look at Twin Studies

Answer Table

Explain

[Actual Test] - A Second Look at Twin Studies

Questions 1-7

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Questions 8-12

Complete the summary below.

Recommended Reading